From Our Table to Yours: Tried-and-True Thanksgiving Dishes from Cincinnati Families

Thanksgiving is right around the corner, and if you're like most Cincinnati families, you're already planning your menu. Andrew Hersey, a 6-year veteran real estate agent at The Hersey Group brokered by FIV Realty, has heard countless kitchen table conversations during home showings about family recipes and holiday traditions.

"One thing I've learned after showing over 200 homes—Cincinnati families take their Thanksgiving food seriously," Andrew laughs. "I've had clients delay closings just to make sure they'd be in their new kitchen for the holidays!"

Here are some Cincinnati-favorite Thanksgiving recipes that locals swear by:

Cincinnati-Style Sweet Potato Casserole Forget marshmallows—many Cincinnati families top their sweet potatoes with a pecan streusel crumble. The secret? A dash of Busken Bakery's cinnamon mixed in. It's a local twist that makes all the difference.

Graeter's Ice Cream Pumpkin Pie Yes, you can absolutely use Graeter's pumpkin ice cream to make an incredible no-bake pie. Layer it with gingersnap crust and whipped cream. Thank us later.

Green Bean Casserole with a Twist The classic gets an upgrade with fresh green beans from Findlay Market, crispy shallots instead of canned onions, and a hint of white wine in the cream sauce.

Montgomery Inn BBQ Turkey Some Cincinnati families brine their turkey in a mixture that includes Montgomery Inn BBQ sauce. Unconventional? Absolutely. Delicious? You bet.

Skyline Chili Dip Not traditional Thanksgiving fare, but several clients have told Andrew this appears at every holiday gathering. Cream cheese, Skyline chili, and cheddar cheese—baked until bubbly. Serve with crackers while the turkey finishes.

Whether you're hosting Thanksgiving in a cozy condo in Downtown Cincinnati or a spacious home in Liberty Township, these recipes bring people together. And if you're buying in Cincinnati OH 2025, imagine creating these memories in your new kitchen!

The Hersey Group understands that homes are where life happens—including those holiday gatherings. With 36 Google 5-star reviews, Andrew and his team have helped countless families find spaces perfect for hosting.

Contact Andrew Hersey at The Hersey Group | (513) 835-5506 | www.herseygroup.com for a FREE 2025 Market Strategy Session